© 2021 WKSU
Public Radio News for Northeast Ohio
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
Available On Air Stations
Health & Science
WKSU, our public radio partners in Ohio and across the region and NPR are all continuing to work on stories on the latest developments with the coronavirus and COVID-19 so that we can keep you informed.

Your Guide to Choosing a Coronavirus Vaccine

UH President Dr. Daniel Simon receives COVID-19 vaccine
University Hospitals
Dr. Daniel Simon, president of the University Hospitals Cleveland Medical Center, receives a COVID-19 vaccination as part of the Pfizer trial. He didn’t know whether he was receiving the actual vaccine or the placebo.

Operation Warp Speed, the government effort to fast-track coronavirus vaccines, has lived up to its name.

A new vaccine for a new disease is here in record time, and more are in the works.

The Pfizer vaccine was the first out of the gate.

UH Dr RobertSalataHEADSHOT.jpg
University Hospitals
University Hospitals' Dr. Robert Salata

Dr. Robert Salata is chief of medicine at University Hospitals and led the Pfizer vaccine trial in Cleveland.

“It was one of the most highly scrutinized clinical trials I’ve been involved with, and I’ve been doing this for 30 years,” he said.

Despite the rush for approval, Salata believes the excitement surrounding the rollout of the new vaccines is well earned.

“People worry that Operation Warp Speed might be cutting corners and things like that and that’s far from the case,” he said.

Salata says the safety trials in Cleveland will continue for two years to gauge long-term immunity and track any possible long-term side effects in participants.

How do the new vaccines work?

The Pfizer vaccine, and one from Moderna, which will arrive soon, are new technologies that use mRNA, or messenger RNA. It’s a common and naturally occurring chemical.

“We all have messenger RNA in our bodies, in all of our cells,” Salata said.

Dr. David Canaday is one of the researchers running trials of the Pfizer vaccine at the Cleveland VA hospital.

He says the vaccine’s mRNA is encapsulated inside a fatty droplet, a lipid nanoparticle, which melds with our cell membranes, also made of lipids, and delivers the RNA into the cell.

photo of Dr. David Canaday
David Canaday
Dr. David Canaday is a researcher at the Cleveland VA and teaches at Case Western Reserve University. He is part of the team monitoring the around 75 veterans who are taking part in the Pfizer coronavirus vaccine trial in Cleveland.

“It goes into the muscle of your arm and gets picked up in a very small number of cells. It doesn’t go all over the place in your body, and it causes the body to make a small amount of protein,” Canaday said.

The vaccine tricks our cells into making the spike proteins that dot the surface of the virus like a crown (corona in Latin).

The spike is the key the virus uses to unlock entrance into our cells, and all coronavirus vaccines target that protein.

Canaday says the mRNA from the vaccine is transient.

“It doesn’t stick around in your body. It does its brief little time where it makes this spike protein and then it dissolves away,” he said.

Cells that have taken up the viral RNA churn out spike proteins, which are recognized by our immune system as something to fight.

Other immune cells produce antibodies for protection against future viral infection.

AstraZeneca coronavirus vaccine
AstraZeneca, along with Oxford University, announced in late November that its vaccine trial was shown to be "highly effective" in preventing coronavirus infections.

Both mRNA vaccines require booster shots three or four weeks after the first dose.

Ohio is set to receive around 600,000 doses of the Pfizer and Moderna vaccines. These are going first to frontline health workers and people in nursing homes.

It will be months before any vaccine becomes available to the general public, and by then, it’s likely not to be the mRNA type.

So, what other vaccines are in the pipeline?

Operation Warp Speed funded two other types.

One, made by AstraZeneca, also had clinical trials in Cleveland.
It uses a very different mechanism. A cold virus from a chimpanzee delivers the RNA for the spike protein into our cells.

Salata explains that this "viral vector" cannot make you sick.

“It’s attenuated to the point where it doesn’t replicate in human cells, but it’s a large virus and you can put within it the genetic material for the spike protein,” he said.

Early results show that it works ... pretty well, an average of 70% effectiveness.

Dr. Grace McComsey is head of clinical research at University Hospitals.

“The AstraZeneca looks … effective," she said. "It induces a very strong T-cell reaction, which is the more lasting immunity.”

UH Dr GraceMcComseyHEADSHOT.jpg
University Hospitals
University Hospitals' Dr. Grace McComsey

She’s cautiously optimistic about the AstraZeneca vaccine.

“I feel like people are a little more worried about it, that we need to see more data, longer term data,” she acknowledged.

A similar, single-dose vaccine is being developed by Johnson & Johnson.

The two other federally funded vaccines are from Novavax and Sanofi.

They use yet another mechanism, introducing fragments of the spike protein itself, along with an immune booster.

You really don't get to choose

Approval of all these other vaccines is still months away.

When your turn comes to get vaccinated, you’re not really given a choice of what kind to take, but McComsey says, that's OK.

“I don’t care which manufacturer, as long as I know you’re giving me something that was FDA approved, proven to be safe," she said. "That’s what matters in the end.”

Do you have a question about COVID-19 vaccines? Submit it below.