News
News Home
Quick Bites
Exploradio
News Archive
News Channel
Special Features
NPR
nowplaying
On AirNewsClassical
Loading...
  
School Closings
WKSU Support
Funding for WKSU is made possible in part through support from the following businesses and organizations.

Lehmans

Hennes Paynter Communications

Northeast Ohio Medical University


For more information on how your company or organization can support WKSU, download the WKSU Media Kit.

(WKSU Media Kit PDF icon )


Donate Your Vehicle to WKSU

Programs Schedule Make A Pledge Member BenefitsFAQ/HelpContact Us
Environment


Ohio Supreme Court justices join the great debate about drilling
Munroe Falls, the state and drilling interests argue who should have a say in where drilling rigs can dig in
by WKSU's M.L. SCHULTZE


Web Editor
M.L. Schultze
 
The Ohio Department of Natural Resources and oil and gas drillers say the state alone should regulate where they put their wells.
Courtesy of TIM RUDELL
Download (WKSU Only)
In The Region:

The courtroom was packed. Nearly twice as much time was allotted. And the Ohio Supreme Court grilled attorneys on all sides in a drilling case that began in Summit County and has environmentalists, communities and corporations nationwide watching closely. WKSU’s M.L. Schultze has more on today’s arguments.

LISTEN: The great debate over drilling in Ohio and who has a say

Other options:
Windows Media / MP3 Download (4:43)


LISTEN: Short version of Supreme Court and drilling debate

Other options:
Windows Media / MP3 Download (1:07)


The high court is deciding two key points in the case of City of Munroe Falls vs. Beck Energy. Both have to do with constitutionally protected home rule.

The first is whether zoning laws can coexist with state law on oil and gas drilling. The second is whether drillers can be required to provide cities with information so they can protect residents.

Beck Energy – and the state – say ‘no’ on both points. They maintain that state law gives the Ohio Department of Natural Resources domain over oil and gas drilling -- anywhere in the state.

Peter Glenn-Applegate laid out the state’s case to a skeptical Justice Paul Pfeifer, as in this exchange:

     “Your honor we think local zoning ordinances trying to restrict oil and gas drilling to particular zones would conflict with the state law.

     “So the position of the state of Ohio through the attorney general is local zoning has no place in the regulation of oil and gas drilling in this state?”

   “Yes, your honor, and if I could I’d like to make two brief points on that.”

The first point is that state law gives ODNR’s division of oil and gas “sole and exclusive authority to regulate location.” The second is that the law requires the state to be careful when it allows drilling in residential areas.

Trust in ODNR?
Pfeifer had reservations.

     “We (citizens) should just trust the good graces of, … just rely on: There are going to be good people at Natural Resources, not to worry?

     “ODNR is absolutely committed to the health and safety of its residents and so it’s not like…

     “I believe it’s the only department that we’ve held in contempt in my tenure here.”

Glenn-Applegate noted that was another ODNR division and said this one is being very careful.

He acknowledged the Munroe Falls drilling would be in a residential area, but noted it is separated by a railroad track and river, and well away from other properties.

What about Shaker Heights?
That’s when Justice William O’Neill jumped in.

     “Let’s talk about Shaker Heights, Ohio, where people have a quarter of an acre. By this statute, as near as I can tell, if ODNR says we’re going to start drilling in a residential neighborhood of Shaker Heights, the municipality of Shaker Heights has nothing to say about that. Is that your position?”

     “Yes your honor as a legal matter, but as a practical matter it would be unlikely for a well to go in there...”

     “We’re in the Supreme Court of Ohio. I don’t care about practical matters. As a legal matter, you’re saying that this statue would permit a driller to go into Shaker Heights and if they convinced ODNR there was money in it for everybody, it would be full speed ahead.”

     “I’m not sure it would be full speed ahead. There would still be several requirements the driller would need to satisfy.”

That would include setbacks and fencing. And in a case of a 4,000-foot well like this one, it would require getting property owners who together control at least 20 acres to say ‘OK.’”

Munroe Falls has its own skeptics
Munroe Falls attorney Thomas Houlihan ran into his own challenges from the justices. Houlihan got off to a rocky start with Justice Terrence O’Donnell.

     “Your argument is that the General Assembly has mandated that there be a local determination of sites, but the Department of Natural Resources has taken it upon itself to determine the location of the wells. Is that right? I’m trying to understand your argument. Is that your argument?

     “No your honor, my argument is this: If a driller wants to drill in a particular location, they have two things to do. They have to go to the ODNR and get approval from the ODNR for that site location and it must be done in compliance with local zoning.”

    “And that’s by a state statute that says that has to be done that way?”

     “No, the state statute doesn’t say anything about local zoning. The home rule amendment gives the power to cities to regulate local zoning.”

Houlihan argued other Supreme Court decisions back that up.

Defining exclusive and location
Justice O’Neill wasn’t giving Houlihan a pass either, even after he cited a case in which drilling was allowed in a neighborhood in his home base of Geauga County and then blew up the property. He kept going back to the wording of the state law. Houlihan argued back.

     “I would disagree with your assessment that the oil and gas statute … says anything about preempting local zoning. It’s silent on local zoning….

     "I’m using the two words in the English language: exclusive and location. If the state is given exclusive control over the location of a building, a structure or a well, isn’t zoning gone?

     "No your honor, because the language has to be read in context.

For its part, Beck Energy rested much of its argument on the state interest in uniform statewide regulation of an industry that is increasingly critical to Ohio – and says the state law clearly recognizes that.

Beck’s argument was joined by a long list of oil and gas interests. Munroe Falls has the backing of other cities, including Broadview Heights and Euclid and local businesses ranging from Zen Small Business Solutions to Sticky Pete’s Maple Syrup.

Add Your Comment
Name:

Location:

E-mail: (not published, only used to contact you about your comment)


Comments:




 
Page Options

Print this page

E-Mail this page / Send mp3

Share on Facebook




Stories with Recent Comments

HOF's Canton expansion could take an island and make it a village
I live in the block from Broad St to the Hall of Fame and will be impacted by the expansion. I am in the process of selling my home and planned to long before i...

Cleveland redeploys police to replace rejected red-light traffic cameras
Periodic rotational enforcement without warning does NOT change behavior and the city officials know that. This is the basis of all officer-run enforcement trap...

New enrollment period offers more insurance options
The removal of federal funding for healthcare CO-OPs may limit the growth of the CO-OP movement. http://www.healthcaretownhall.com/?p=6381

The family of Boardman vet killed in Vietnam receives his medals
My name is Mike Eisenbraun. I am Larry's brother. I was 14 years old when Larry was killed in Vietnam. He has been gone for 46 years but it seems like yester...

Cleveland seniors are creating new wealth -- and facing new challenges
Why is anyone surprised that we people over 65 are not retiring? If you have been paying attention, defined company funded pensions were phasing out in the eigh...

Ohio company cuts off a dairy supplier after allegations of animal abuse
these people should be held accountable for their actions. i would be more than pleased to see a year or more behind bars. i will NEVER eat anything that comes ...

Goodyear recruits thousands of vets
What a wonderful interview! Excellent reporting skills by a talented young reporter! I look forward to hearing more from Ms. Schley!

Ohio Democratic Party begins the rebuilding process
I agree 100% with Sen. Brown. I think it is absolutely critical for the Democratic Party in Ohio to engage in the long, tedious, hard task of re-building from t...

They're talking again in the Macedonia bridge dispute
Norfolk Southern says the Ledge road bridge meets regulations for train traffic, however it was built as an overpass for a roadway and/or farm usage. I think t...

Cleveland City Council to consider transgender public restroom law
this is sick. I do not want my daughter in the same bathroom as a perverted 45 year old man. this proposed legislation could seriously damage the security of ch...

Copyright © 2014 WKSU Public Radio, All Rights Reserved.

 
In Partnership With:

NPR PRI Kent State University

listen in windows media format listen in realplayer format Car Talk Hosts: Tom & Ray Magliozzi Fresh Air Host: Terry Gross A Service of Kent State University 89.7 WKSU | NPR.Classical.Other smart stuff. NPR Senior Correspondent: Noah Adams Living on Earth Host: Steve Curwood 89.7 WKSU | NPR.Classical.Other smart stuff. A Service of Kent State University