News
News Home
Quick Bites
Exploradio
News Archive
News Channel
Special Features
NPR
nowplaying
On AirNewsClassical
Loading...
  
School Closings
WKSU Support
Funding for WKSU is made possible in part through support from the following businesses and organizations.

Northeast Ohio Medical University

Hospice of the Western Reserve

Greater Akron Chamber


For more information on how your company or organization can support WKSU, download the WKSU Media Kit.

(WKSU Media Kit PDF icon )


Donate Your Vehicle to WKSU

Programs Schedule Make A Pledge Member BenefitsFAQ/HelpContact Us
Environment


High Court hears arguments in Munroe Falls drilling case
Broader issues of home rule and oil and gas regulation are involved 
by WKSU's TIM RUDELL


Reporter
Tim Rudell
 
Ohio Supreme Court Justices. The Court will hear oral arguments in the Munroe Falls / Beck Energy case
Courtesy of Ohio Supreme Court
Download (WKSU Only)
In The Region:

A century ago, Ohio' constitution was amended to give cities “home rule.” Last decade, the Ohio Legislature took away some of that authority by stripping communities of local control over oil and gas development.  And this week, a legal battle over how far lawmakers could go with that has made its way to the Ohio Supreme Court.  WKSU' Tim Rudell reports.   

Click to listen

Other options:
Windows Media / MP3 Download (4:01)


In this corner
Munroe Falls is an Akron suburb. Beck Energy is an oil and gas driller from Ravenna. Beck wants to drill in Monroe Falls and the city is trying to use its ordinances on drilling permits, zoning and right-of-ways to stop them. And THAT, has set off a court fight drawing in dozens of other communities and having statewide implications.

State versus local
Jonathan Entin, of Case-Western Reserve University’s law school: “Actual gas operations affect people right near the wells.  So local governments want to protect their communities, whereas the state is saying, ‘This is such an important matter, and the resource itself does not follow city limits, we need to have one comprehensive system of regulation, and put the authority at the state level.’”

Lawmakers in Columbus
The Legislature did that in 2004 with House Bill 278. And the surge in oil and gas development with the evolution of fracking has made it a much bigger issue since.

To critics, the law was designed just to keeps environmental and other controls out of the way of developers. For backers, H.B. 278 was necessary so a morass of local rules didn’t bog down energy exploration.

The idea
But the bill’s sponsor, then state legislator Tom Neihaus – a Republican from Clermont County Former State Senator Tom Niehaus-- says there was a more practical reason for the bill. “We have a large number of townships and villages and cities all of whom have an interest in the gas and old development, the question is, do any have the expertise to regulate these industries.   My determination and that of my colleagues was that, no, this was a highly technical area and we needed to have the expertise of the Ohio Department of Natural Resources.”

Another view
State Rep. Bob Hagan – a Democrat from Mahoning County -- opposed the 2004 law and is pushing a counter measure in the current legislature. “I spoke out against it. State legislator Bob HaganI thought that those individuals that would be impacted directly by gas drilling should have a say so in the decision making process. Now, fast forward, and say to the local governments: ‘Sorry but we’re going to drill where we want, we’re going to have our way with your roads and bridges. I think what we have now is an opportunity to try to rectify that.”

Meanwhile, in court
The Munroe Falls case began in 2011, with the city taking Beck Energy to Summit County Common Pleas Court for drilling without a local permit and ignoring zoning and street ordinances.  The city won. 

Beck appealed and the 9th District Court of Appeals said the city has no permitting authority for drilling — only the state has that. But the city won on enforcing its other ordinances—so long as it doesn’t discriminate against drillers.  Both Munroe Falls and Beck were unhappy with the decisions and asked the Ohio Supreme Court to hear the case.

More than meets the eye
But, professor Entin says the points to be argued Wednesday morning are really surface waves on a deeper current of debate. “Whatever the Ohio Supreme Court Decides will not be the last word. I think this is a big, complicated set of issues, people feel very strongly about those issues, and they will proceed from the court’s decision to figure out what is the best way to keep their side of the argument going forward with the best chance for success down the road.”Ohio Supreme Court

Entin talked about what some of those “ways” might be. “If Monroe Falls wins on the drilling-permit issue, a lot of other communities are going to be tempted to adopt similar measures. If they lose on the big issue, but they win on the right of way regulation, the battle may move in that direction.  And, of course, if the Court says that the State can do everything, that it has all the cards here, then the way to change that, presumably, would be to change the Legislature.”

Both sides are supported
by dozens of interested parties.  Backers of Munroe Falls range from cities like Broadview Heights, Euclid and Mansfield to Sticky Pete’s Maple Syrup Farm.  On the Beck side there are: the city of Heath, the Chambers of Commerce of Canton and of Ohio, as well as companies, unions and trade associations. 

Add Your Comment
Name:

Location:

E-mail: (not published, only used to contact you about your comment)


Comments:




 
Page Options

Print this page

E-Mail this page / Send mp3

Share on Facebook




Stories with Recent Comments

There's no off-season for the Cleveland International Film Festival
I would like to see "The Murders of Brandywine Theater" filmed by local Larry Longstreth shown at the Cleveland International Film Festival!

Study shows raising the cigarette tax a dollar could raise $342 million
So, it takes an expert to tell us raising the tobacco tax raises the revenue for the state? Doh. By the way, any one who was going to quit smoking probably alre...

Akron's Highland Square celebrates community spirit and public art
Both Donna and her husband, Joseph are both such amazing art talents! The photos look stunning! I must get down to Angel Falls for an in-person look. I just l...

Pluto: Another off-season, another Browns quarterback conundrum
The Browns do need a draftable QB for the future. Johnny Manziel needs to go and that leaves Brian Hoyer and Connor Shaw. Free agency doesn't really have any so...

Exploradio: Improving the lives of paralyzed people
God bless you doctor. I hope to be alive the day that humans, like me, can use the results of your search...

Nature and nourishment down by the river at the Metroparks' Merwin's Wharf
I love QUICKBITES! I look forward to it every week. One question: is it possible to include a link to the restaurant or store that you profile? Thanks!

Canton's proposed Timken-McKinley school merger is drawing spirited debate
From a sports opinion Varsity would have a lot more talent to choose from So Im sure varsity sports would improve.Also Timkens name would be much more published...

Canton school board will decide whether to merge high schools
I really hope we can save those jobs, usually we try to cut budgets but the demand is still the same. Then we look bad a year or two after the descion is made. ...

FirstEnergy wants PUCO guarantees on nuclear and coal prices
Would just comment that the plant has admitted the following (as reporting in the Akron Beacon Journal): "The utility has said it may have difficulty keeping t...

Mozzarella's easy when you have a way with curd
Hello, Where can I get such a heater that you have? Does it hold temperature that you set? What brand and model is it? Thank you in advance!! :)

Copyright © 2015 WKSU Public Radio, All Rights Reserved.

 
In Partnership With:

NPR PRI Kent State University

listen in windows media format listen in realplayer format Car Talk Hosts: Tom & Ray Magliozzi Fresh Air Host: Terry Gross A Service of Kent State University 89.7 WKSU | NPR.Classical.Other smart stuff. NPR Senior Correspondent: Noah Adams Living on Earth Host: Steve Curwood 89.7 WKSU | NPR.Classical.Other smart stuff. A Service of Kent State University